The Annunciation Church Shooting: Love Always Defeats Evil

Reflections on the shooting, the grief of families, and the courage that gives hope for the future.

Jesse Merkel’s father stood at the podium grieving and, somehow, still speaking. Fletcher was only eight years old. He and ten-year old Harper Moyski were the children murdered inside the Annunciation Church, adjacent to the Catholic school.

Supported by the principal, who placed a steadying hand on his shoulder, Jesse delivered his statement:

“Yesterday, a coward decided to take our 8-year-old son, Fletcher, away from us. Because of their actions, we will never be allowed to hold him, talk to him, play with him, and watch him grow into the wonderful young man he was on the path to becoming.”

Watch the full statement here.

The Principal’s eyes looked down, as the words sank in, the weight of the cross around his neck heavy.

On that first day of school, the church was full: children on one side, parents and faculty on the other. A few minutes into the Mass, gunfire rang out. Two kids died and 17 others injured.

Yet, even amid horror, stories of courage bring me hope for the future of my four children.

Twelve-year old Astoria Safe, now with a bullet fragment that will remain in her skull, prayed: “I need your help. Please. I want all my friends to be safe. Help me to be safe.”

Westin Halsne, age 10, was saved by his friend Victor. In a pew two seats away from the weapon held through the stain glass window, shots rang out. Kids scrambled to lay under the pew. Victor shielded Westin with his own body, taking a bullet himself. Westin escaped with only gunpowder on his neck. Watch below for more.

Pat Scallen, who lived half a block away, ran to the church when he heard shots. Two young girls emerged, one with a severe head wound. Through tears, she begged him: “Please, just hold my hand. Hold my hand. Hold my hand.” Pat stayed until EMTs arrived. Watch his story below.

There are many more stories of heroism. I don’t know if recounting them brings comfort to those directly impacted, but for me, they kindle hope in the world we are leaving to future generations. Still, ultimate hope can only be found in Christ. Through Him, we receive the love needed to act according to His will. Love always defeats evil.

“Harper was a bright, joyful, and deeply loved 10-year-old whose laughter, kindness, and spirit touched everyone who knew her.”

Harper Moyski’s parents’ joint statement

Jesse Merkel’s spoken words mark the beginning of an unwanted journey. Only a man of faith could speak through such anguish. The agony in his voice and eyes struck me to my core. Survivors now carry the cross, continuing forward in pain and faith. One day—God willing—they will be reunited with Fletcher and Harper in heaven.

Peace.

P.S. The New Earth series continues next week.